
The Midnight Book Club by David Rice exposes how library apps like Hoopla give the appearance of almost unlimited access to digital books, but the financial reality is more like a Communist bread line.
The article's conclusion:
"The daily budget cap system employed by libraries using Hoopla
results in a digital checkout system that can be exhausted by a small
number of users within hours of the daily reset. The Christian County
Library's $40,000 annual budget translates to approximately 44-55 daily
checkouts—a number so small that just 10-15 active users can consume the
entire day's allocation before most patrons begin their day.
This
analysis explains why patrons frequently encounter "daily budget limit
reached" messages and why these messages often appear earlier in the day
as the month progresses and more patrons become aware of popular new
content.
While digital content should theoretically allow
unlimited simultaneous access, the commercial model behind Hoopla
creates an artificial scarcity that significantly limits the practical
value of the library's extensive digital collection."
The Christian County Library has just limited patrons' checkout for Hoopla items from 5 to 3. See below. Rice reports the library's budget for Hoopla is about $40,000 annually. Read his article to see what the numbers add up to.
